Around the Nation
2:37 pm
Wed December 4, 2013

Pipeline On Wheels: Trains Are Winning Big Off U.S. Oil

Originally published on Wed December 4, 2013 6:28 pm

The oil boom in the United States is creating another boom — for the railroad industry.

So far this year, in North Dakota alone, 140 million barrels of oil have left on trains. Shipments of crude oil by rail are up almost 50 percent over last year — and this upward trend is expected to continue.

A visit to the world-famous Tehachapi Loop, part of a winding mountain pass in Southern California, demonstrates the scale and reach of the oil boom in the middle of the country. As a train full of oil tanker cars rumbles past, it's hard not to think of it as a pipeline on wheels.

And the railroads? They love it.

"Over the course of the last almost four years, you've seen just a rapid development, which attests to the demand for the oil," says John Miller, a vice president for BNSF Railway.

Railroads are in a good position, he says, with tracks by all the major oil fields. Their main competition is pipelines — and those take a long time to build. Just think about the stalled Keystone XL.

Right now, in many places, existing pipelines don't have enough capacity to move all of the oil to major markets.

"A pipeline, typically speaking, requires commitments and time to put those together, and time to get permitting, and time to lay the pipe, and time to put it all together — and that could take years," Miller says.

The industry doesn't want to wait that long. So far this year, 60 percent of all oil produced in North Dakota left the state by rail.

"It's amazing when you look at it that way," says transportation consultant Chuck Clowdis of the Colorado-based firm IHS. "That's a lot of trains. That's a lot of tanks moving down a lot of track."

Clowdis says there's an overwhelming need to move all this oil to market, and the railroads have so far proved that they're the most efficient.

At least, they are when they can find enough rail cars to do the job. There's a backlog of orders in the thousands. "Just finding the tankers right now is the biggest challenge," Clowdis says.

But the growth doesn't come without resistance.

On the West Coast, there's a big push to build new oil rail terminals and retrofit refineries to handle trains. In Bakersfield, Calif., for example, trains could connect with existing pipelines that feed Los Angeles to the south and the Bay Area to the north.

But it's also a good place to illustrate challenges that crude oil by rail faces. At the nearby Tehachapi Loop mountain pass, freight trains wind and grind around corner after corner as they descend almost 4,000 feet to the valley floor.

That loop was an engineering marvel when it was opened in 1876. But today, even after improvements over the years, it still has bottlenecks and pinch points along the route. That worries some people who live in the valley, including environmentalist Tom Frantz.

"Any kind of derailment with a few sparks somewhere, and you can have a major disaster up there," he says.

Frantz is concerned about the what-ifs on that pass, especially after a high-profile derailment in Canada last summer killed more than 40 people. Then, in November, a crude oil train derailed in Alabama and caught fire.

Frantz says these are reasons to slow down.

"Are they going to start pushing this crude coming in before they get everything as safe as it needs to be?" he says. "Are they going to wait for a big accident before they change how they do things on that rail line?"

But the slowdown Frantz wants isn't too likely on the West Coast, or across the rest of the country.

The railroads are quick to point out that hazardous material spills and other accidents are way down in the past 30 years. According to the Association of American Railroads, hazmat train accident rates have declined by 90 percent since 1980.

And with states like North Dakota predicted to set another record this year for oil production, rail lines are shooting for new records of their own.

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

MELISSA BLOCK, HOST:

The U.S. oil boom in North Dakota and elsewhere is also creating a boom for the railroad industry. So far this year, trains have carried 140 million barrels of oil out of North Dakota alone. It's because there just isn't enough pipeline capacity to move all of that product to major markets. Overall, shipments of crude oil by rail are up almost 50 percent over last year.

And as NPR's Kirk Siegler reports, the trend is only expected to grow.

KIRK SIEGLER, BYLINE: To understand the scale and reach of the oil boom in the middle of the country, come to this wind-y mountain pass in Southern California.

(SOUNDBITE OF TRAIN HORN)

SIEGLER: Here, at what's known as the world-famous Tehachapi Loop, watching a train full of oil tanker cars, let's see, one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, 10.

(SOUNDBITE OF TRAIN)

SIEGLER: Standing there with the train rumbling past, it's hard not to think of this as a pipeline on wheels. And the railroads, they love it.

JOHN MILLER: Over the course of the last almost four years, you've seen just a rapid development, which attests to the demand for the oil.

SIEGLER: That's John Miller. He's vice president of industrial sales for Burlington Northern Santa Fe Railroad. He says railroads are in a good position, with tracks by all the major oil fields. And their main competition, pipelines, they take a long time to build. Just think about the stalled Keystone XL.

MILLER: A pipeline, typically speaking, requires commitments and time to put those together and time to get permitting and time to lay the pipe and time to put it all together. And that could take years.

SIEGLER: And the industry doesn't want to wait that long. So far this year, 60 percent of all the oil produced in North Dakota left the state by rail.

CHUCK CLOWDIS: It's amazing when you look at it that way. That's a lot of trains. That's a lot of tanks moving down a lot of track.

SIEGLER: Economist Chuck Clowdis of consulting firm IHS says there's an overwhelming need to move all this oil to market and the railroads have so far proven they're the most efficient. That's when they can find enough rail cars to do the job.

CLOWDIS: Just finding the tankers right now is the biggest challenge.

SIEGLER: Clowdis says they can't build these new tank cars fast enough. There's a backlog of orders in the thousands. And then there's the question of where all that oil is going. Here on the West Coast, there's a big push to build new oil rail terminals and retrofit refineries to handle trains.

(SOUNDBITE OF MACHINERY)

SIEGLER: One is proposed at this refinery in Bakersfield. Here, trains could connect with existing pipelines that feed L.A. to the south and the Bay Area to the north. But take Bakersfield. It's a good place to illustrate other challenges that crude by rail faces. Remember that Tehachapi Loop? Freight trains wind and grind around corner after corner as they descend almost 4,000 feet to the valley floor. That loop was an engineering marvel when it was built in 1876. There have been improvements over the years, but there are still bottlenecks and pinch points along the way. And that worries some people that live in the valley.

TOM FRANTZ: Any kind of derailment with a few sparks somewhere and you can have a major disaster up there.

SIEGLER: Tom Frantz is an environmentalist who's worried about the what-ifs up on that pass, especially after a high-profile disaster in Canada this past summer.

(SOUNDBITE OF NEWS REPORT)

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN: A train carrying crude oil went off the tracks in the center of Lac-Megantic. The derailment sent off a chain reaction, a series of explosions that turned into an inferno.

SIEGLER: That derailment killed more than 40 people. Then, in November, a crude oil train derailed in Alabama and caught fire. Tom Frantz says this is all the more reason to slow down.

TOM FRANTZ: Are they going to start pushing this crude coming in before they get everything as safe as it needs to be? Are they going to wait for a big accident before they change how they do things on that rail line?

SIEGLER: The railroads are quick to point out that hazmat spills and other accidents are way down in the past 30 years. The slowdown Frantz wants isn't too likely here on the West Coast or across the rest of the country. With states like North Dakota predicted to set another record this year for oil production, you can bet on rail lines shooting for new records of their own. Kirk Siegler, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.