Education
12:15 am
Wed June 20, 2012

A New Union Battle As Chicago Teachers, Mayor Clash

Originally published on Wed June 20, 2012 5:08 am

There hasn't been a school strike in Chicago for 25 years. But the current contract between Chicago teachers and the Chicago Public Schools expires at the end of next week, and tensions between the teachers union, the school district and Mayor Rahm Emanuel are ratcheting higher.

Chicago Teachers Union members outmaneuvered the mayor, school officials and anti-union education groups by overwhelmingly approving a measure that allows teachers to strike if contract negotiations fall flat.

About 90 percent of CTU's membership — nearly 24,000 workers — voted this month to support a strike if one is called.

The dispute has prompted comparisons to Wisconsin, where a firestorm over collective bargaining ultimately resulted in a recall election there earlier this month.

Tensions Running High

CTU President Karen Lewis says the strong vote in Chicago is an indication of the rocky relationship between the union and the school board. It also demonstrates "the absolute abject lack of respect and scapegoating of teachers, paraprofessionals and clinicians throughout this country," she says.

"That's all we hear," Lewis says. "[That] everything that's wrong with the educational system is our fault."

In the past year, Emanuel stripped teachers of a 4 percent pay raise, and his effort to institute longer school days while sidestepping the union contract has infuriated union members.

Emanuel also wants more privately run charter schools in the city, which the teachers union opposes.

A change in state law also angered teachers. Aimed at preventing a strike, the new law set the threshold for a strike authorization vote at 75 percent — and ruled that those members who don't vote would be considered "no" votes.

Michael Bochner, an art teacher at Cesar Chavez Elementary School, says that when teachers learned of the provision, they realized the law was a huge effort to blunt the union's power.

"So here at Chavez, we had 100 percent participation on the first day [of voting], which is much more than we've had for any election ever before," Bochner says.

Emanuel denies that his support for the change in the law backfired — but he did acknowledge last week that the strong 90 percent vote is a "huge number."

'No Wisconsin Here'

School district and union negotiators are wrangling over wages, class size and other issues. Even so, Emanuel offered a small olive branch last week as he talked about the wide gap in the two sides' proposals for teacher pay raises.

"They deserve it. They've earned it and appropriately have gotten it, and should get it in the future," Emanuel said. "What I want to make sure is our children also have a full day and full school year equal to their full potential, which has not been done to date."

Chicago Public Schools CEO Jean-Claude Brizard adds that no one in the city is looking to mirror Wisconsin, which grabbed the country's attention for months after Gov. Scott Walker introduced contentious changes curtailing the collective bargaining ability of most public-sector unions.

"No Wisconsin here — and I don't think we need Wisconsin here," Brizard says. "But ... I don't want my kids being caught in the middle of all of this. I don't want my families anxious about what's going to be happening in September."

Robert Bruno, a labor professor at the University of Illinois, Chicago, says that while both the union and school board can draw lessons from the Wisconsin saga, Emanuel — former chief of staff to President Obama — may have another question to consider.

"How exactly does it look to have a major collective-bargaining dispute — a strike of public-sector workers — in his home city, on the eve of a tight presidential election with battleground states all around Illinois?" Bruno asks.

It may not come to that. Both the union and the school board say they're looking for common ground as the negotiations continue. And, says CTU's Karen Lewis, that 90 percent strike authorization vote is making those negotiations just a little bit easier.

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

LINDA WERTHEIMER, HOST:

The fight over collective bargaining in Wisconsin grabbed the country's attention for months. Governor Scott Walker recently survived a recall triggered by that fight. Now, there's a public union battle brewing in neighboring Illinois. Members of the Chicago Teachers Union outmaneuvered the mayor, school officials and anti-union education groups and overwhelmingly approved a measure which allows them to strike if contract negotiations fail. NPR's Cheryl Corley has more.

CHERYL CORLEY, BYLINE: There hasn't been a school strike in Chicago for 25 years. But the current contract between Chicago teachers and the Chicago Public Schools expires at the end of next week.

Recently, about 90 percent of the union's membership - nearly 24,000 workers - voted to support a strike if it's called. CTU President Karen Lewis says it was an indication of the rocky relationship between the union and school management and...

KAREN LEWIS: The absolute abject lack of respect and scapegoating of teachers, paraprofessionals and clinicians throughout this country. I mean that's all we hear. Everything that's wrong with the educational system is our fault.

CORLEY: Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel's wants more privately run charter schools. He stripped teachers of a 4 percent raise and his effort to institute longer school days while side-stepping the union contract infuriated union members. Add to that a change in state law that set the threshold for a strike authorization vote at 75 percent.

(SOUNDBITE OF PAPER BEING RIPPED)

CORLEY: During the last day of school at Cesar Chavez Elementary School last week, art teacher Michael Bochner watched as other teachers ripped huge sheets of colored paper from rolls as they prepared for an evening celebration for students. Bochner says when teachers learned the new state law aimed at preventing a strike would count people who didn't vote as no votes, teachers realized it was a huge effort to blunt the union's power.

MICHAEL BOCHNER: So here at Chavez, we had 100 percent participation on the first day, which is much more than we've ever had for any election ever before.

CORLEY: Mayor Emanuel denied that his support for the change in the state law backfired but he did acknowledge the strong 90 percent vote.

MAYOR RAHM EMANUEL: It's a huge number.

CORLEY: Negotiators for the school district and the union are wrangling over wages, class size and other issues. Even so, Emanuel offered a small olive branch as he talked about the wide gap in the proposals for teacher pay raises.

EMANUEL: They deserve it. They've earned it and appropriately have gotten it and should get it in the future. What I want to make sure is our children also have a full day and full school year equal to their full potential, which has not been done to date.

CORLEY: Chicago's Schools CEO Jean-Claude Brizard adds that no one in Chicago is looking to mirror Wisconsin by trying to do away with negotiating rights.

JEAN-CLAUDE BRIZARD: No Wisconsin here - and I don't think we need Wisconsin here. But again, what I want is I don't want my kids being caught in the middle of all of this. I don't want my families anxious about what's going to be happening in September.

CORLEY: University of Illinois-Chicago labor Professor Robert Bruno says although there are lessons that both the union and school board can takeaway from the Wisconsin saga, he says Mayor Emanuel, former chief of staff to President Obama, may also have another question to consider.

ROBERT BRUNO: How exactly does it look to have a major collective bargaining dispute - a strike of public sector workers in his home city on the eve of a tight presidential election with battleground states all around Illinois?

CORLEY: It may not come to that. The union and school leaders say they're looking for common ground as the negotiations continue and CTU President Lewis says the 90 percent strike authorization vote is making those negotiations just a little bit easier.

Cheryl Corley, NPR News- Chicago.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

WERTHEIMER: You're listening to MORNING EDITION from NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.